Space debris is growing exponentially and is a threat to destroy or degrade the systems we depend on for communication, weather, GPS, position/navigation/timing, financial transactions, national security, and more. There are no internationally binding rules to control it, mitigate it, or clean it up.
In addition to millions of pieces of space debris, Earth's orbital shells are congested with an ever-increasing number of satellites and objects (both active and defunct). Orbital capacity is limited and is at risk of loss or degradation as first movers occupy them with little or no regulation or management.
The space powers (US, China, Russia) and their allies have declared space to be a "warfighting" domain despite treaty obligations to the contrary. National militaries feed billions every year to the military-industrial complex to escalate and dominate each other, and inviting conflict by intention, miscalculation, mistake, or misperception.
Space activities are now driven principally by greed and the desire for domination and control. In philosophical terms, space is a Hobbesian or Machiavellian state of nature where conventional ethics and morality have been displaced by a Nietzshean "will to power."
The governance of space is controlled primarily by three countries: the U.S., China, and Russia. There is no effective international democratic institution that can check these countries' actions, impose binding rules on them, or sanction their unlawful, dangerous, malicious, or negligent behavior.
Powerful, well-resourced nations and corporations are: (1) occupying Earth's orbits with their satellites and space objects and (2) seeking to occupy areas of the Moon, Mars and other celestial bodies to extract and appropriate resources. Both are in violation of a plain reading of the Outer Space Treaty.
Just as previous empires (from ancient Greece and Rome to the later empires of the British, French, Dutch, etc.) dominated the seas and the continents (and their inhabitants), a handful of powerful nations, wealthy corporations, and billionaires now dominate and monopolize space physically, politically, legally, economically, socially, and culturally.
Despite the fact that the Outer Space Treaty emphasizes the exploration and use of space on the basis of equality across all nations, a small number of spacefaring nations essentially control all space launches and resources (satellites, launch services, etc.). They unilaterally determine how the benefits are accessed and distributed, and at what price. This has created extraordinary inequality and inequity.
As the small number of first-mover spacefaring countries occupy prime orbital pathways and seek to occupy celestial bodies (including the Moon, Mars, and asteroids), they will capture, or intend to capture, in-situ resources, including valuable mined substances like water and rare-earth minerals. These exploitations are occurring despite the fact that these nations have no legal claim of ownership of these resources under the Outer Space Treaty.
More and more dangerous debris is reentering the atmosphere and landing near humans and property without any enforceable rules to ensure compliance, safety, and compensation. Liability rules for in-space incidents are nonexistent. Commercial human spaceflight safety rules are essentially nonexistent except for what companies voluntarily decide to provide.
Governments, militaries, and corporations control all the the narratives of space (including the legal interpretations of what is considered lawful and unlawful) by way of their command of, and influence over, political institutions, courts, funding, resources, and job/career opportunities. Their agendas and interests dominate all venues (media, academia, government activities, lobbying, etc.) and any calls for a check on these forces are marginalized, suppressed, and ignored.
Powerful first-mover spacefaring nations leverage their political, military, technological, informational, and economic superiority to unilaterally act in space. This creates unequal bargaining power in relations with all other nations. This power is then used to shape bi-lateral agreements and international law to guarantee their sole capture and control of the space domain.

The U.S. Artemis Accords and the China/Russia ILRS are both bi-laterally negotiated, multi-nation agreements. The objective of both is to occupy and exploit the Moon. It pits the U.S. and China/Russia against each other in a "race" to capture lunar resources. Despite claims that they comply with international law, they are an attempt to circumvent both U.N. processes and the prohibition against appropriation in the Outer Space Treaty.

The nations, militaries, and corporations that dominate space constantly demand more and more tax dollars and control based on the fear they manufacture that competitors will surpass and subordinate us. Money and control must be handed over to them without question, deliberation, or contemplation. This is leading to increasingly bad outcomes, as shown by the current debris, congestion, and military escalation data.

In space, objects like satellites and vehicles can very easily serve both civilian (i.e., peaceful) and military purposes. A satellite can be maneuvered to innocently collect data, or it can be turned into a kamikaze-type weapon against other objects or vehicles. A repair arm can be used to fix a friendly satellite, or disable/destroy an adversary's satellite. Currently, there are no binding rules to define or govern the use of these technologies. This has increased the risk of miscalculation, misperception, and mistake between adversaries, which increases the potential for conflict and war.

The cost of launching rockets and objects into space is dropping rapidly. At the same time, physical and cyber security rules and enforcement mechanisms are limited, and capabilities across operators vary widely. Satellites have been commandeered or hacked. And, we are now vulnerable to terrorists or malicious actors who may launch weapons to destroy our satellites and degrade our orbital shells.

Those who control space feed the public a steady diet of space exploration propaganda (such as living on the Moon or Mars) in order to entice and capture lucrative government contracts. In reality, humans cannot survive long term in space. We can advance scientific knowledge and discovery without wasting hundreds of billions of tax dollars on foolish and dangerous attempts to build orbital hotels or to colonize the Moon or Mars
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.